Wolves loving lambs
The stillness of her body, something reminiscent of inertia and also of defenselessness, made her wonder, nevertheless, what she was waiting for to leave, what signal she was waiting for before she stepped out of the field between the watching mirrors and opened the door and disappeared. --2666, p. 115
Thursday, May 3, 2012
5/3--1:25pm--Milton Hall Basement
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
1:40 pm, Milton Hall Basement, April 24
Tuesday, April 17, 2012
Thursday, March 15, 2012
3/15, Milton Basement, composed in blogger (2pm)
In an aside, I just made this blog available to my chair, which means that it may now actually be reflection-in-presentation, even though I doubt even she could follow the theoretical shorthand I'm writing with here...
Anyway, I do want to reflect on my (1) teaching and (2) research:
Teaching: Last week, the midterm week (or close enough anyway) I asked students to tell me what they would change with the class. Almost to a person (in written free writes) they complained about what they saw as busy work and asked to have more fun. The busy work they were complaining about was the fact that they had to complete 4 rhetorical analysis worksheets for different artifacts. I guess I can see this as busy work because of the repetition, but I also noticed that the RAs for the most part were better than I've gotten in the past. Then again, I modelled completing the worksheets pretty heavily, so they may have just been copying my work, and giving it back to me. In fact a lot of them did. Does that count as reflective imitation? Can I assume that it does or it doesn't without really knowing what they're decision making processes were like? Am I really asking them to do something that provides an experience on which they're likely to productively reflect?
Anyway, as a result of those midterm evaluative free writes, I've really tried to make the class more fun. I also had a number of one on one office hour visits, which I think those students liked (or during which I charmed them, at least) and I think that energy is seeping into the classroom at large. Anyway, it maybe seems like it's working a little bit. At least they can see (I think) that I'm trying to listen to them and take their advice. I did, after all, have one debate. And I tried to model research techniques in real time with a game called Stump Seth, but I think that game was just super boring because they already know (or think they're experts in) internet research.
How interesting that I jump back to using my perceptions of their attitudes and writing in and for class as evidence of their internal states? Why am I so obsessed with what goes on in a student's mind that remains hidden from me, or perhaps even from them?
(2) Research: Also coming along pretty well. I've been outlining my project a lot, and I think I've gotten to the point where I can murder some darlings (which will make everything simpler, I'm sure), and that I'm finding maybe some overriding organizational principles for the whole dang thing. I'm not quite where I want to be in terms of page count over timeline, but I still think that if I put as much work as I can in over Spring Break (next week...), it might very well be possible to defend the first 3 chapters as a full proposal this semester.
And I just met with my chair (should she have an alias? does it matter?) and we talked about some of these organizational principles. I think we both like the idea of categorizing reflection by the sites in which it occurs. Kind of. Because "site" is probably the wrong word. Students and teachers are going to reflect on and in action in a way that makes such reflection invisible, often even to the person doing the reflection. Reflection in presentation, then, becomes the only way we have access to someone's thinking about the motives and outcomes for past action as a way to anticipate the problems of future action, which presentation is, in my definition, a text. So then we have the texts of reflection as well as the roles of the people doing the reflection. And I'm going to say that even though these roles are different, understanding them as being fundamentally similar will help us to see the relationship between teaching and writing, both of which are multimodally communicative and rhetorical.
Phew.
Saturday, March 10, 2012
Tuesday, February 21, 2012
Reflection 2/21 –3:45pm, Milton Hall Basement
(Written in [with? on? through?] Word. On [see last bracket] my computer.)
So I think I have a couple of problems, which I just thought about as I was thinking about my reflection for the day, which is one of the problems. And I’m going to list these problems now so that I don’t forget. Which means I’m going to come back to them. Which pulls me into the old stream of consciousness loop problem. Which is another problem for the list…
1. I don’t think I’m reflecting now.
2. I’m not surprised by this reflection which suggests that I’m somehow planning it, which suggests that I ought to be reflecting on the planning but I can’t because I’m not writing as I’m planning.
3. I can’t represent my own thoughts.
So. 1. I’m not reflecting now, or at least not reflecting in the way I’m going to ask my students to reflect because of the old problem of linear time. In other words, here I am supposedly reflecting on an ongoing process but at the same time developing ideas with which I’m hoping to fulfill the process. That doesn’t make a lot of sense I realize. To rephrase: I’m not reflecting on anything because I haven’t really done anything. I suppose I could reflect on the teaching I did today, or the writing. Which I will. As point 4.
2. I’m fully aware that I’m going to sit down to reflect when I pace outside in the sunshine. Which means I’m planning my reflection. Which actually probably suggests that I’m hyper aware (neurotically aware?) of the rhetorical situation for which I’m composing these reflections. I suppose I want to create some data that will support my findings, but I don’t have any findings. Which means that I’m trying to anticipate something that hasn’t really happened, which then means that I want these reflections to reflect my actual thoughts. Which is the stream of consciousness loop problem or what Corder calls trying to see the backs of my own eyeballs—in other words, I’m trying to write in a way that, after analysis, provides some insight into my own process or whatever, insight that I’m not aware of as I’m sitting here typing. But for me the whole point of reflection is current, mindful awareness of rhetorical situations, including mode. Which I guess I’m doing. So it is successful, except for the fact that the audience is yours truly, just some months in the future and try as I might, I can’t anticipate or maybe hope that I can’t anticipate what it is that this future Seth will find. Or create.
And I’m going to skip over 3. because it feels like a pretty old and well established idea. It does make me think of Kerouac and Woolf and Faulkner, though, and I really like all of those people and I appreciate the kind of breathless vivid tone that those writers evoke.
Okay, so…reflecting on teaching. Today was a day for working in pairs on practice peer review for their rhetorical analysis essays. If I want to I can include the assignment prompt which is, I think, pretty self-explanatory, but not to my students. Actually, I believe it is clear to my students, but they never read it. In fact, I said just that to my sister on the phone today. And I just wrote about how as a new teacher I made what I implied was a mistake in trying to diagnose behavioral reasons for student’s less than stellar work.
Anyway, I started class with an attendance question: what is your favorite birthday? I chose this one as I was walking into the room because I get the sense that the class isn’t cohering into a community in exactly the way I want it to. Part of this, I think, is the rows of desks and my position, standing, at the front of the room. Anyway, I was hoping that by talking about birthdays we’d develop the kind of community that it seesm the class is struggling or just plain doesn’t want to develop.
Then I gave a brief introduction to…I don’t really know what. I definitely spoke. And I made the point—that the lib pedagogy folks routinely make—that academic writing or identities are simply another performance of another piece of a shattered, fluid identity. In other words, I told them that writing with academic voice is like putting on a bow tie. They seemed to perk up at the silliness. But I also think I touched some of them with my optimism that they will succeed or else that their failure doesn’t really reflect too poorly on them as people. It’s actually, now that I think about it, one of the central ways that I try to get my students to like me: the ways that I invoke a pretty cheesy self-help voice to make them feel my respect and awe for the world that I fully believe we re-create everyday with language.
Then we had a presentation based on a Blackboard discussion that involved a debate about the nature of religion and the role of religion in public life. I think the discussion went well, but I know (have known for a long time now) that I like to talk and that I will railroad a group’s discussion if they aren’t participating enough or bringing up the ideas that I want them to bring up. In a lot of ways, I’m right there with them, kind of competing just as I always have, for the smartest comment in the classroom. I always win. Always. I also wanted to write a little about my two Native American students who seem quiet and on their phones and not listening and who haven’t really participated in the class so far. But we’ll see, right? I’ll try more and more to involve them in our class discussions, but I also want to respect their shyness or at the very least the choice they are consciously invoking to remain silent. But, unfortunately, and hugely, I don’t think these students really want to be participating in this institution or don’t feel confident enough to. Which means they’re probably not very strong writers. Which means, again, that I’m anticipating the reactions of a future Seth.
As for my writing. I don’t know what I’m doing. I’m basically free writing the introduction with the hopes that I’ll be able to salvage a lot of it with revision. I can’t bring myself to read it, and last week out of exhaustion or laziness I imported the whole (including reference pages) specialized comps answer into the intro. I read the answer at least. But I don’t know if it belongs where it is. Or if it answers any question I raise. Maybe I should try writing subheadings that are questions. And then I can answer those questions and revise and end up with something good. But I haven’t been able to bring myself to cut the comps answer because I need to get done with this thing already, and I find it much easier to work on a document that will be long when it already appears long. I’m not going to touch that thing until tomorrow.s
Thursday, February 16, 2012
Tuesday, February 14, 2012
Failure (technically)
- Assigning reflective writing (at least my Rhetorical and Research Narrative assignments) is a way to force students to think in a certain way. This is a little problematic because I don't want to think that I'm trying to change a student's mental function...you could almost call it a colonization of the mind. This kind of assignment also suggests that I don't trust that students are thinking about what I want them to. Or I don't know what they're thinking. And we're back to a dissertation about thought, about turning a mind inside out so that the thought processes are visible, which isn't 1) possible or 2) ethical?
- I felt uncomfortable talking into a machine, so much so that near the end I began addressing my "transcriber" who though she will never exist for this lost recording, was a necessary palliative to the awkwardness of talking to myself. I'll leave the analysis of this for a later stage.
- I couldn't transparently relate my thought processes, especially as I was speaking. My stuttering and loud "ums" meant that I was choosing words, but it happened so quickly (the choosing) that I couldn't record the choosing. Makes me think that this reflection thing may be more difficult than I thought.
(1/31/12, 12:30pm, Milton Hall Basement)
So…this si the first one which means that I’m probably going to get more and more used to this as the study progresses, which also means that this is probably going to be pretty rough and already I can see that I’m rambling and already I’m thinking about how I could code this and already that I started with an apology for the form of something that I don’t know if I’ll ever read again (though of course I will and my articulating that I won’t just gives more fuel to the coding fire…which is to say that I’m reflecting on a study of reflection which means that I can pretty much write these reflections so that they inform my hypotheses for the study and even though I’ll try not to, I don’t know if that’s possible (see for example, everything I’ve just written).
Anyway, perhaps I ought to guide my own reflections in future…or at least I should mention something about the fact that I’ll be recording my reflections using this kind of alphabetic text, on my computer, once a week, and also via audio recording once a week. Another challenge I’m totally going to face here is…I forget…totally lost my train of thought. Now I remember. I’ve got to be careful that my reflection doesn’t change my practice because of the institutional limitations put on my study by my IRB approval. In other words, I think that IRB is limiting my classroom research/ teacher inquiry method because it fixes a method whose strength, as I see it, is constant adaptability in the face of reflective practice. Thus, my provisional title (the reflective practice of reflective practice) ought to be changed to the institutionally mediated semi-reflected on (in presentation) practice of reflective practice. Or not.
I had another idea just a second ago…I was thinking about the IRB and institutional limitation, but I can’t remember.
But I am thinking about the nature of these reflections, this one I’m writing right now. It might very well be quoted in my dissertation, which means that I’m fully aware of a pretty hardcore audience and I’m finding myself already, as I type these words, explaining things to that audience (providing the provisional title for example…I know goddamn well what the thing is called…) even though I’m not supposed to be explaining things to that audience. And I’m leaving in typos. Because I’m trying to write quickly so as to maintain the kind of immediate writing that might (hopefully) expose some of my tacit understandings of context, but also because it seems more genuine, even though in other classes when I’ve typed journals or other reflective writing I almost always fix the typos because they drive me nuts. I’m probably going to fix these typos, too.
Which brings me to a couple of preliminary analyses…
It’s so easy to fix typos on a computer, and so difficult to make them when handwriting. Next week, I’ll hand write my reflections, and see what happens. That would be a pretty easy pedagogical shift, too.
Because ultimately I do want to be important and I think that the best way to do that is to be innovative which means you have to change things. Which is a big assumption, especially for a budding researcher (such a gross metaphor and yet I use it all the time, why?) to admit to because of course that means that a huge amount of findings, namely all the findings that came before, aren’t as useful or true as the one I want to hang my ego on, etc.
But I’m also working in my personal life at not being quite so self-deprecating because what I just wrote was probably also a symptom of my habitual negative self-talk which I kind of enjoy because it lets me see myself as tortured or whatever, instead of simply a super earnest white guy English teacher which for lots and lots of reasons I don’t wish to feel like.
God, it’s been like 11 minutes since I started reflecting and I already have so much…my data set is going to be fucking huge.
I definitely need to set some guidelines for this reflective writing…I’ll probably want to ask myself the same questions that I ask my students…And I wonder if I need to ignore the temporal factor.
Now that I’m thinking of it
But I remember what I was going to write before which is that my big contribution what I hope will make me rich and famous is that conscious awareness of the modal affordances in the physical classroom on Monday mornings will make us better more effective teachers.
But that’s not what I’m studying, is it? See…already I want to change my research design, even after 12 minutes now of writing. I’m fucked. Or I don’t know, I’m sure I’m not, but…
I’m studying the ways that the affordances of different modes affect reflection. And I have to stick to that. And I have to remember Manal’s advice to only let the analysis go a level or two deep, even though I’m really more personally concerned with the greatest depths, the depths at which all ideas become one idea (which I don’t know if I really believe, but I like the aesthetic of it, so…)
Alright, well, I’m sure that’s enough for now. Clocked in at 15 minutes and 900 some words.

